'They're all talk': How the Five Star Movement lost southern Italy's support
After soaring to power in 2018 on a wave of support from southern Italian voters hoping for long-awaited change, the Five Star Movement is now languishing in the polls. Where did it all go wrong?
Vincenzo Zoppi leans over the balcony of his cramped Naples apartment, surveying his impoverished neighbourhood he says has been betrayed by Italy's politicians.
"You know when they come? When there are elections," the 70-year-old former mechanic says, adding that his vote for the Five Star Movement in 2018 will be his last.
READ ALSO: What election promises have Italy’s political parties made so far?
"They all have the same idea: 'I have to get that position and when I get my seat, it's over.' They'll never do anything."
His view of the once anti-establishment party is widely shared in Naples, Italy's third-largest city, as the country prepares to vote on September 25.
Like most of southern Italy, Naples -- with an unemployment rate more than double the national average - overwhelmingly supported Five Star in the last general election.
Many were drawn by its flagship ‘citizen's income’ benefit for the unemployed, as well as its anti-austerity programme and rejection of traditional politics.
Residents in the Sanita district of Naples, which overwhelmingly supported Five Star in the last general election. Photo: Carlo Hermann / AFP
But the grassroots support that fuelled the movement has ebbed away, with polls now putting Five Star on less than a third of the 33 percent it won in 2018.
"Those who voted for you because you were the disruptive force to empower the south, won't vote anymore," said Matteo Brambilla, 53, a former Naples city councillor who quit Five Star last October.
"They're not credible anymore."
The Five Star Movement identifies as neither left nor right, and started out on a strongly eurosceptic, environmentalist, anti-austerity platform focused on tackling poverty and corruption while repudiating career politicians.
But four years in government has taken its toll on the movement.
"Five Star were the expression of a huge protest against the failure of traditional parties," said Giovanni Orsina, head of the Luiss School of Government in Rome.
"But from the moment you get into government, at that point the protest ends," he said.
READ ALSO: Political cheat sheet: Understanding Italy’s Five Star Movement
Former Five Star Movement (M5S) leader Luigi Di Maio in happier times, when he enjoyed strong support in Naples at elections in 2018. Photo by Carlo Hermann / AFP
The party has allied with political opponents in office - first the anti-immigrant League, then the left-leaning Democratic Party, and finally joining almost all of Italy's parties last year as part of the grand coalition led by Mario Draghi.
With these shifts have come policy reversals, public rifts between party leaders and accusations of cronyism, while former members complain decisions are now imposed from Rome rather than developed from the ground up.
Five Star has also shed lawmakers, losing more than half of its deputies and 45 percent of its senators since 2018, according to a YouTrend study.
The defectors include Foreign Minister Luigi Di Maio, a former party leader from outside Naples who had put a more professional face on the movement founded by irreverant, combative comedian Beppe Grillo in 2009.
Di Maio quit in June along with dozens of lawmakers, accusing current Five Star leader Giuseppe Conte of trying to thwart Draghi's pro-European, Atlanticist agenda.
Photo by Carlo Hermann / AFP
A month later, Conte withdrew his support for Draghi's government, triggering a crisis that led to snap elections.
Conte - a former law professor brought in as a technocratic premier following the 2018 vote, before being replaced by Draghi - has been trying to save Five Star from oblivion by emphasising its anti-establishment roots.
"We are the more progressive force, it's obvious," he has insisted, citing the party's battle for a nine euro-per-hour minimum wage.
Five Star's platform this year also includes tax breaks for hiring young people, protections for indebted homeowners, credits for green building projects and opposition to oil and gas drilling.
The universal citizen's income remains a flagship policy, which the party claims has allowed one million Italians to escape poverty - many of them in Naples.
READ ALSO: Will Italy’s hard right win the election with a ‘super majority’?
Photo by Carlo Hermann / AFP
More than 161,000 families, or over 13 percent of greater Naples' population, received on average 637 euros from the scheme in June, according to the most recent figures from the National Social Security Institute.
But the scheme has been attacked for supposedly encouraging unemployment and fraud, with Italian media regularly reporting cases of mafiosi, non-citizens and others said to have illegally received the payment.
In the alleys of Naples' Sanita quarter, where fading funeral notices cover crumbling walls and fruit stands remind shoppers they can pay with the welfare debit card, resident Giuseppe Capuozzo vowed to "never again" vote for Five Star.
"It was a disaster. Economically, nothing. They talk, talk, talk," said Capuozzo, his white scooter laden with grocery bags.
"But us, who's helping us?" he asked.
A market in the Sanita district of Naples. Photo by Carlo Hermann / AFP
Comments
See Also
Vincenzo Zoppi leans over the balcony of his cramped Naples apartment, surveying his impoverished neighbourhood he says has been betrayed by Italy's politicians.
"You know when they come? When there are elections," the 70-year-old former mechanic says, adding that his vote for the Five Star Movement in 2018 will be his last.
READ ALSO: What election promises have Italy’s political parties made so far?
"They all have the same idea: 'I have to get that position and when I get my seat, it's over.' They'll never do anything."
His view of the once anti-establishment party is widely shared in Naples, Italy's third-largest city, as the country prepares to vote on September 25.
Like most of southern Italy, Naples -- with an unemployment rate more than double the national average - overwhelmingly supported Five Star in the last general election.
Many were drawn by its flagship ‘citizen's income’ benefit for the unemployed, as well as its anti-austerity programme and rejection of traditional politics.
But the grassroots support that fuelled the movement has ebbed away, with polls now putting Five Star on less than a third of the 33 percent it won in 2018.
"Those who voted for you because you were the disruptive force to empower the south, won't vote anymore," said Matteo Brambilla, 53, a former Naples city councillor who quit Five Star last October.
"They're not credible anymore."
The Five Star Movement identifies as neither left nor right, and started out on a strongly eurosceptic, environmentalist, anti-austerity platform focused on tackling poverty and corruption while repudiating career politicians.
But four years in government has taken its toll on the movement.
"Five Star were the expression of a huge protest against the failure of traditional parties," said Giovanni Orsina, head of the Luiss School of Government in Rome.
"But from the moment you get into government, at that point the protest ends," he said.
READ ALSO: Political cheat sheet: Understanding Italy’s Five Star Movement
The party has allied with political opponents in office - first the anti-immigrant League, then the left-leaning Democratic Party, and finally joining almost all of Italy's parties last year as part of the grand coalition led by Mario Draghi.
With these shifts have come policy reversals, public rifts between party leaders and accusations of cronyism, while former members complain decisions are now imposed from Rome rather than developed from the ground up.
Five Star has also shed lawmakers, losing more than half of its deputies and 45 percent of its senators since 2018, according to a YouTrend study.
The defectors include Foreign Minister Luigi Di Maio, a former party leader from outside Naples who had put a more professional face on the movement founded by irreverant, combative comedian Beppe Grillo in 2009.
Di Maio quit in June along with dozens of lawmakers, accusing current Five Star leader Giuseppe Conte of trying to thwart Draghi's pro-European, Atlanticist agenda.
A month later, Conte withdrew his support for Draghi's government, triggering a crisis that led to snap elections.
Conte - a former law professor brought in as a technocratic premier following the 2018 vote, before being replaced by Draghi - has been trying to save Five Star from oblivion by emphasising its anti-establishment roots.
"We are the more progressive force, it's obvious," he has insisted, citing the party's battle for a nine euro-per-hour minimum wage.
Five Star's platform this year also includes tax breaks for hiring young people, protections for indebted homeowners, credits for green building projects and opposition to oil and gas drilling.
The universal citizen's income remains a flagship policy, which the party claims has allowed one million Italians to escape poverty - many of them in Naples.
READ ALSO: Will Italy’s hard right win the election with a ‘super majority’?
More than 161,000 families, or over 13 percent of greater Naples' population, received on average 637 euros from the scheme in June, according to the most recent figures from the National Social Security Institute.
But the scheme has been attacked for supposedly encouraging unemployment and fraud, with Italian media regularly reporting cases of mafiosi, non-citizens and others said to have illegally received the payment.
In the alleys of Naples' Sanita quarter, where fading funeral notices cover crumbling walls and fruit stands remind shoppers they can pay with the welfare debit card, resident Giuseppe Capuozzo vowed to "never again" vote for Five Star.
"It was a disaster. Economically, nothing. They talk, talk, talk," said Capuozzo, his white scooter laden with grocery bags.
"But us, who's helping us?" he asked.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.