Italian police violated Amanda Knox's human rights: European court
Europe's top rights court on Thursday ordered Italy to pay thousands of euros in damages to Amanda Knox, the American student acquitted in 2015 of the gruesome killing of her British housemate after spending years behind bars.
The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, said Italian authorities failed to provide a lawyer for Knox in the initial days of an eight-year legal drama which made global headlines.
She served four years in prison over the November 2007 killing of her roommate, British exchange student Meredith Kercher.
Knox and her boyfriend at the time, Raffaele Sollecito, were convicted of the murder despite their denials of any involvement. Knox's sentence was stiffened to 28 years in prison when the conviction was upheld in 2014, though both she and Sollecito were acquitted by Italy's top court the following year.
That court later denounced "major flaws" in the police's handling of the investigation, as well as the absence of a "body of evidence" allowing for a safe conviction or any admissible DNA evidence linking the pair to the murder.
READ ALSO: 'Meredith Kercher should not be forgotten'
Photo: © John Kercher, supplied by TJMK
In the meantime Knox filed a claim with the European court of unfair treatment at the hands of the Italian police, in particular during overnight questioning on November 6th, 2007.
She claimed she was slapped on the head twice during the interrogation, and forced to speak despite being exhausted and unable to show "discernment or willpower".
Knox also said she was not assisted by an independent and professional interpreter, but only a police employee who acted instead as a "mediator" who encouraged her to "imagine hypothetical scenarios".
'I was in shock'
Kercher's half-naked body was found on November 2nd, 2007, in a back room of the apartment she and Knox shared in the central city of Perugia. The 21-year-old had been stabbed 47 times and had her throat slashed. Police also found signs of sexual assault.
During the initial questioning, Knox eventually accused her former manager at a pub of murdering Kercher -- a statement she signed but then withdrew. The manager was eventually released without charge, prompting prosecutors to accuse Knox of making a "malicious accusation".
The rights court judges ruled that Italian authorities had improperly denied access to a lawyer and failed to assess the conduct of the police interpreter, which had "compromised the fairness of the proceedings as a whole".
READ ALSO:
-
Amanda Knox vs Italy: European court accepts rights violation case
-
Meredith Kercher murder case: Italy blocks new review
-
Timeline: the key dates in the Kercher murder case
"I was in shock, and I volunteered to help the Perugian police in any way I could," Knox said in a statement after Thursday's ruling, citing 53 hours of questioning over five days "without a lawyer, in a language I understood maybe
as well as a 10-year-old".
"When I told the police I had no idea who had killed Meredith, I was slapped in the back of the head and told to 'Remember!'," she said.
But while faulting Italian authorities for not investigating Knox's claims of mistreatment and violence, the court found no evidence of "inhuman or degrading treatment".
€18,400 in damages
Knox nonetheless thanked the court for "acknowledging the reality of false confessions".
She had sought €500,000 in damages and an additional €2.2 million for legal and travel costs incurred by her and her parents, who travelled from their home in Seattle, Washington, to be at her side during the years of legal proceedings. But the court ordered Italy to pay only €18,400 in damages and legal costs.
While Knox and Sollecito were in jail, Italian police arrested an Ivory Coast-born drifter and small-time drug dealer named Rudy Guede over the murder.
The judge in Guede's fast-track trial in 2008 ruled that he could not have acted alone, a decision which prosectors seized on to pursue the charges against Knox.
Guede has insisted he is innocent, saying he had consensual sex with Kercher before going to the bathroom, where he listened to loud music on his headphones, and when he came back out she had been attacked. But an Italian court last year denied a review of his conviction, upholding his 16-year sentence.
Since her release Knox has returned to Seattle, where she works as a journalist. She has also written a memoir of her ordeal, 'Waiting To Be Heard'.
READ ALSO: Knox trial puts fear into American students
Photo: Tizana Fabi/AFP
By AFP's Clémentine Rigot
Comments
See Also
The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, said Italian authorities failed to provide a lawyer for Knox in the initial days of an eight-year legal drama which made global headlines.
She served four years in prison over the November 2007 killing of her roommate, British exchange student Meredith Kercher.
Knox and her boyfriend at the time, Raffaele Sollecito, were convicted of the murder despite their denials of any involvement. Knox's sentence was stiffened to 28 years in prison when the conviction was upheld in 2014, though both she and Sollecito were acquitted by Italy's top court the following year.
That court later denounced "major flaws" in the police's handling of the investigation, as well as the absence of a "body of evidence" allowing for a safe conviction or any admissible DNA evidence linking the pair to the murder.
READ ALSO: 'Meredith Kercher should not be forgotten'
Photo: © John Kercher, supplied by TJMK
In the meantime Knox filed a claim with the European court of unfair treatment at the hands of the Italian police, in particular during overnight questioning on November 6th, 2007.
She claimed she was slapped on the head twice during the interrogation, and forced to speak despite being exhausted and unable to show "discernment or willpower".
Knox also said she was not assisted by an independent and professional interpreter, but only a police employee who acted instead as a "mediator" who encouraged her to "imagine hypothetical scenarios".
'I was in shock'
Kercher's half-naked body was found on November 2nd, 2007, in a back room of the apartment she and Knox shared in the central city of Perugia. The 21-year-old had been stabbed 47 times and had her throat slashed. Police also found signs of sexual assault.
During the initial questioning, Knox eventually accused her former manager at a pub of murdering Kercher -- a statement she signed but then withdrew. The manager was eventually released without charge, prompting prosecutors to accuse Knox of making a "malicious accusation".
The rights court judges ruled that Italian authorities had improperly denied access to a lawyer and failed to assess the conduct of the police interpreter, which had "compromised the fairness of the proceedings as a whole".
READ ALSO:
- Amanda Knox vs Italy: European court accepts rights violation case
- Meredith Kercher murder case: Italy blocks new review
- Timeline: the key dates in the Kercher murder case
"I was in shock, and I volunteered to help the Perugian police in any way I could," Knox said in a statement after Thursday's ruling, citing 53 hours of questioning over five days "without a lawyer, in a language I understood maybe
as well as a 10-year-old".
"When I told the police I had no idea who had killed Meredith, I was slapped in the back of the head and told to 'Remember!'," she said.
But while faulting Italian authorities for not investigating Knox's claims of mistreatment and violence, the court found no evidence of "inhuman or degrading treatment".
€18,400 in damages
Knox nonetheless thanked the court for "acknowledging the reality of false confessions".
She had sought €500,000 in damages and an additional €2.2 million for legal and travel costs incurred by her and her parents, who travelled from their home in Seattle, Washington, to be at her side during the years of legal proceedings. But the court ordered Italy to pay only €18,400 in damages and legal costs.
While Knox and Sollecito were in jail, Italian police arrested an Ivory Coast-born drifter and small-time drug dealer named Rudy Guede over the murder.
The judge in Guede's fast-track trial in 2008 ruled that he could not have acted alone, a decision which prosectors seized on to pursue the charges against Knox.
Guede has insisted he is innocent, saying he had consensual sex with Kercher before going to the bathroom, where he listened to loud music on his headphones, and when he came back out she had been attacked. But an Italian court last year denied a review of his conviction, upholding his 16-year sentence.
Since her release Knox has returned to Seattle, where she works as a journalist. She has also written a memoir of her ordeal, 'Waiting To Be Heard'.
READ ALSO: Knox trial puts fear into American students
Photo: Tizana Fabi/AFP
By AFP's Clémentine Rigot
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.