Italian MPs approve revised budget after EU standoff
Italian lawmakers passed Saturday the populist government's revised 2019 budget before a year-end deadline, despite complaints from the opposition that it was dictated by Brussels and had been rammed through without debate.
The coalition of the anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and the far-right League party expressed their approval with a vote of confidence that saw 327 deputies for and 228 against, with one abstention.
Key measures in the big-spending budget were watered down as the government tried to avoid being punished by the European Commission and financial markets.
Senators passed the draft last week with a vote of confidence that avoided discussing around 700 amendments put forward by the government but provoked acrimonious scenes over the lack of substantive debate.
Similar scenes were repeated on Friday in the lower house, where the session was suspended after copies of the budget were thrown around, and in the chamber on Saturday.
If next year's budget had not passed before December 31, the government would have been forced to continue to function on a monthly basis using the 2018 budget.
"There was no deliberate wish by the government to avoid discussion," Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte told an end-of-year press conference on Friday as the opposition Democratic Party filed a complaint with the Constitutional Court over the sidelining of parliament.
Conte, a lawyer, is not a member of either of the ruling parties and has worked to achieve compromises between the parties and with Brussels since the government was formed in June.
In a historic first, in October the European Commission rejected Italy's big-spending budget, which promised a universal basic income and scrapped pension reform.
But Italy last week agreed to reduce the cost of both of its landmark measures, and is now committed to not adding to its colossal two-trillion euro debt load next year.
'End poverty'
In the latest hiccup to the tightly balanced revised budget, charities were on Thursday up in arms over a sudden decision to double their tax rate from 12 to 24 percent.
M5S leader and Deputy Prime Minister Luigi Di Maio bore the brunt of criticism as he had said the budget would "end poverty".
He said there was no time to remove the measure before the end of the year and so the law would have to be changed again in January.
Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini's League has also had to climb down on costly pension reform.
The government has struggled to come up with a budget that pleases their voters, Brussels and the market, with many Italians complaining about measures being watered down to placate the European Commission.
The EU and Italy negotiated intensely with both sides worried that a protracted feud would alarm the markets and ignite a debt crisis in the eurozone's third biggest economy.
Without the compromise, Italy would have ultimately faced a fine of up to 0.2 percent of the nation's GDP after a long and rancorous process with its eurozone partners.
The talks centred on the so-called structural deficit, which includes all public spending minus debt payments.
Italy's first budget was set to blow through commitments made by the previous government, and require Rome raising even more debt.
Last week's deal anticipates that this will now be balanced, with the overall deficit target lowered to 2.04 percent of GDP.
"It's not at all true that the budget was written in Brussels, it was written in Italy," Conte insisted on Friday.
Italy's public debt is a big problem and now sits at a huge 2.3 trillion euros or 131 percent of Italy's GDP -- way above the 60 percent EU ceiling.
Comments
See Also
The coalition of the anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and the far-right League party expressed their approval with a vote of confidence that saw 327 deputies for and 228 against, with one abstention.
Key measures in the big-spending budget were watered down as the government tried to avoid being punished by the European Commission and financial markets.
Senators passed the draft last week with a vote of confidence that avoided discussing around 700 amendments put forward by the government but provoked acrimonious scenes over the lack of substantive debate.
Similar scenes were repeated on Friday in the lower house, where the session was suspended after copies of the budget were thrown around, and in the chamber on Saturday.
If next year's budget had not passed before December 31, the government would have been forced to continue to function on a monthly basis using the 2018 budget.
"There was no deliberate wish by the government to avoid discussion," Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte told an end-of-year press conference on Friday as the opposition Democratic Party filed a complaint with the Constitutional Court over the sidelining of parliament.
Conte, a lawyer, is not a member of either of the ruling parties and has worked to achieve compromises between the parties and with Brussels since the government was formed in June.
In a historic first, in October the European Commission rejected Italy's big-spending budget, which promised a universal basic income and scrapped pension reform.
But Italy last week agreed to reduce the cost of both of its landmark measures, and is now committed to not adding to its colossal two-trillion euro debt load next year.
'End poverty'
In the latest hiccup to the tightly balanced revised budget, charities were on Thursday up in arms over a sudden decision to double their tax rate from 12 to 24 percent.
M5S leader and Deputy Prime Minister Luigi Di Maio bore the brunt of criticism as he had said the budget would "end poverty".
He said there was no time to remove the measure before the end of the year and so the law would have to be changed again in January.
Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini's League has also had to climb down on costly pension reform.
The government has struggled to come up with a budget that pleases their voters, Brussels and the market, with many Italians complaining about measures being watered down to placate the European Commission.
The EU and Italy negotiated intensely with both sides worried that a protracted feud would alarm the markets and ignite a debt crisis in the eurozone's third biggest economy.
Without the compromise, Italy would have ultimately faced a fine of up to 0.2 percent of the nation's GDP after a long and rancorous process with its eurozone partners.
The talks centred on the so-called structural deficit, which includes all public spending minus debt payments.
Italy's first budget was set to blow through commitments made by the previous government, and require Rome raising even more debt.
Last week's deal anticipates that this will now be balanced, with the overall deficit target lowered to 2.04 percent of GDP.
"It's not at all true that the budget was written in Brussels, it was written in Italy," Conte insisted on Friday.
Italy's public debt is a big problem and now sits at a huge 2.3 trillion euros or 131 percent of Italy's GDP -- way above the 60 percent EU ceiling.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.