Report details Karolinska errors in Macchiarini case
A new report has slammed the prestigious Karolinska Institute (KI) medical university for committing multiple errors in the case of Italian surgeon Paolo Macchiarini, whose trachea operations in Sweden caused controversy when patients died.
Last week an external investigation led by Kjell Asplund, chairman of the Swedish National Council on Medical Ethics, revealed that KI exerted pressure on the Karolinska University Hospital to hire the disgraced celebrity surgeon.
And a separate report headed by Sten Heckscher, former president of the Supreme Administrative Court of Sweden, on Monday outlined errors committed in the case by KI, the university closely linked to the hospital.
Excuses have been coming thick and fast since Asplund’s investigation said that Macchiarini should not even have been employed at the hospital where he carried out experimental synthetic trachea operations on critically ill individuals. Several resigned in its wake.
On Friday meanwhile, KI chairman Lars Leijonborg left his post on the same day that he was given the results of the Heckscher review. Leijonborg denied that criticism was behind his resignation.
Heckscher's report blasts KI for not investigating Macchiarini's background more before hiring him, particularly after negative reviews of his performance emerged from previous employers.
"I have never seen the like of these negative references. They certainly don't mince their words. He was for example mentioned in Italian media and was not considered competent for employment in Florence," Heckscher told a press conference on Monday morning. "Those references would make anyone think twice."
KI has apologized for its actions in the Macchiarini case, but only after the Karolinska University Hospital did so first, while the institute has also subsequently recognized that it put pressure on the hospital to hire the surgeon.
Developments in the Macchiarini affair are far from over: in total around a dozen inquiries into his operations in Sweden are under way.
The Italian attained world fame after completing the first synthetic trachea transplant using stem cells in 2011.
He was reported to the Swedish authorities by four doctors as early as 2014, but an internal probe cleared him of research misconduct and carrying out procedures without ethical permission.
Comments
See Also
Last week an external investigation led by Kjell Asplund, chairman of the Swedish National Council on Medical Ethics, revealed that KI exerted pressure on the Karolinska University Hospital to hire the disgraced celebrity surgeon.
And a separate report headed by Sten Heckscher, former president of the Supreme Administrative Court of Sweden, on Monday outlined errors committed in the case by KI, the university closely linked to the hospital.
Excuses have been coming thick and fast since Asplund’s investigation said that Macchiarini should not even have been employed at the hospital where he carried out experimental synthetic trachea operations on critically ill individuals. Several resigned in its wake.
On Friday meanwhile, KI chairman Lars Leijonborg left his post on the same day that he was given the results of the Heckscher review. Leijonborg denied that criticism was behind his resignation.
Heckscher's report blasts KI for not investigating Macchiarini's background more before hiring him, particularly after negative reviews of his performance emerged from previous employers.
"I have never seen the like of these negative references. They certainly don't mince their words. He was for example mentioned in Italian media and was not considered competent for employment in Florence," Heckscher told a press conference on Monday morning. "Those references would make anyone think twice."
KI has apologized for its actions in the Macchiarini case, but only after the Karolinska University Hospital did so first, while the institute has also subsequently recognized that it put pressure on the hospital to hire the surgeon.
Developments in the Macchiarini affair are far from over: in total around a dozen inquiries into his operations in Sweden are under way.
The Italian attained world fame after completing the first synthetic trachea transplant using stem cells in 2011.
He was reported to the Swedish authorities by four doctors as early as 2014, but an internal probe cleared him of research misconduct and carrying out procedures without ethical permission.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.