Star Wars director loses Sweden 'droid battle'
Lucasfilm, the production company of Star Wars director George Lucas, has lost its bid to prevent a Swedish firm from registering the trademark "Brandroid" despite concerns it is too similar to other Lucasfilm "droid" trademarks.
Back in early 2011, Stockholm-based digital branding services company Ocean Observations filed forms with Sweden's Patent and Trademark Registration Office (PRV) to register the name "Brandroid".
"The name is a combination of the word 'brand' and 'Android'," Ocean Observations founder Sofia Svanteson told The Local.
She explained the name stemmed from a project the company had been working on for a client based in Japan aimed at designing a more user-friendly interface for devices used on the Android operating system.
A short time later, however, the company received a letter from Lucasfilm expressing concerns about the "Brandroid" trademark.
The Star Wars director's company, which has several trademarks registered in Sweden – including "Droid", "Droids", and "Idroids" referring to "intelligent robots in the six films included in the Star Wars film series", feared that the Ocean Observations trademark could cause confusion among consumers.
Lucasfilm claimed that its trademark was "included in its entirety in BRANDROID" and that "the trademarks are visually and aurally similar" and therefore interchangeable.
According to Swedish law, a trademark can't be registered if "it is identical with or similar to an older brand trademark for goods or services of the same or a similar type" or if there is a risk they could be confused with one another.
However, when Svanteson received word of the complaint, she and her company simply dismissed it.
"We couldn't imagine that the objection would be taken seriously so we ignored it," she said.
"There are tons of names out there with the word 'droid' in them."
The Swedish patent office agreed with Svanteson's view, finding in a recently filed ruling that Lucasfilm's complaint had no merit.
While PRV admitted that there were similarities between the class of goods and services for which the Lucasfilm and Ocean Observation trademarks had been registered, the agency found there was little chance that consumers would be confused by the two because "BRANDROID" is viewed as a made up word with no connection to the meaning that the term "DROID" has by itself.
Moreover, PRV disputed that "Brandroid" would really be pronounced in a manner that would emphasize "-droid", arguing speakers would likely pronounce it "brand-roid".
Svanteson at Ocean Observations said she was "happy" to hear that the patent agency had rejected Lucasfilm's complaint, but emphasized that her company had never been concerned about it in the first place.
"I'm glad the matter is over, but we were never worried. It felt like the complaint was some sort of automatic response they send out any time someone registered a trademark anywhere with the word 'droid' in it," she told The Local.
David Landes
Comments
See Also
Back in early 2011, Stockholm-based digital branding services company Ocean Observations filed forms with Sweden's Patent and Trademark Registration Office (PRV) to register the name "Brandroid".
"The name is a combination of the word 'brand' and 'Android'," Ocean Observations founder Sofia Svanteson told The Local.
She explained the name stemmed from a project the company had been working on for a client based in Japan aimed at designing a more user-friendly interface for devices used on the Android operating system.
A short time later, however, the company received a letter from Lucasfilm expressing concerns about the "Brandroid" trademark.
The Star Wars director's company, which has several trademarks registered in Sweden – including "Droid", "Droids", and "Idroids" referring to "intelligent robots in the six films included in the Star Wars film series", feared that the Ocean Observations trademark could cause confusion among consumers.
Lucasfilm claimed that its trademark was "included in its entirety in BRANDROID" and that "the trademarks are visually and aurally similar" and therefore interchangeable.
According to Swedish law, a trademark can't be registered if "it is identical with or similar to an older brand trademark for goods or services of the same or a similar type" or if there is a risk they could be confused with one another.
However, when Svanteson received word of the complaint, she and her company simply dismissed it.
"We couldn't imagine that the objection would be taken seriously so we ignored it," she said.
"There are tons of names out there with the word 'droid' in them."
The Swedish patent office agreed with Svanteson's view, finding in a recently filed ruling that Lucasfilm's complaint had no merit.
While PRV admitted that there were similarities between the class of goods and services for which the Lucasfilm and Ocean Observation trademarks had been registered, the agency found there was little chance that consumers would be confused by the two because "BRANDROID" is viewed as a made up word with no connection to the meaning that the term "DROID" has by itself.
Moreover, PRV disputed that "Brandroid" would really be pronounced in a manner that would emphasize "-droid", arguing speakers would likely pronounce it "brand-roid".
Svanteson at Ocean Observations said she was "happy" to hear that the patent agency had rejected Lucasfilm's complaint, but emphasized that her company had never been concerned about it in the first place.
"I'm glad the matter is over, but we were never worried. It felt like the complaint was some sort of automatic response they send out any time someone registered a trademark anywhere with the word 'droid' in it," she told The Local.
David Landes
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.