Broken tsunami warning system wastes millions
Germany has invested €45 million in a network of buoys that are supposed to warn Asians of an impending tsunami. But they don't work and even if they did they might be useless, according to news reports.
According to the Süddeutsche Zeitung, the buoys are meant to be on the high seas off Indonesia as part of an early warning system conceived after the devastating 2004 tsunami that killed tens of thousands of people.
But at least one has been lost after a ship ran into it, while several more are still waiting to be deployed. Officials have lost contact with others because Indonesian authorities apparently haven’t maintained them correctly.
“All the infrastructure was handed over in March, so the responsibility now lies with the Indonesians,” said Jörn Lauterjung of Potsdam’s German Centre for Geosciences, who helped lead the project.
But even if the buoys could be made to function, the entire project might be a waste of money because existing land-based seismic equipment already does a good job of detecting incoming tsunamis.
“In my opinion, is the cost-benefit factor is so bad that one should abstain from offshore buoy systems,” Ulrich Wolf, head of the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission, told Focus magazine.
Indonesian officials disagree and say they’d like the buoys to be repaired. They told German TV network ARD that their country was being put at risk.
“The buoys are the heart of the system," a government official said. "They are urgently needed if one wants to know whether there really is a tsunami."
The Local/mdm
Comments
See Also
According to the Süddeutsche Zeitung, the buoys are meant to be on the high seas off Indonesia as part of an early warning system conceived after the devastating 2004 tsunami that killed tens of thousands of people.
But at least one has been lost after a ship ran into it, while several more are still waiting to be deployed. Officials have lost contact with others because Indonesian authorities apparently haven’t maintained them correctly.
“All the infrastructure was handed over in March, so the responsibility now lies with the Indonesians,” said Jörn Lauterjung of Potsdam’s German Centre for Geosciences, who helped lead the project.
But even if the buoys could be made to function, the entire project might be a waste of money because existing land-based seismic equipment already does a good job of detecting incoming tsunamis.
“In my opinion, is the cost-benefit factor is so bad that one should abstain from offshore buoy systems,” Ulrich Wolf, head of the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission, told Focus magazine.
Indonesian officials disagree and say they’d like the buoys to be repaired. They told German TV network ARD that their country was being put at risk.
“The buoys are the heart of the system," a government official said. "They are urgently needed if one wants to know whether there really is a tsunami."
The Local/mdm
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.